00:27 <dgilmore> anyone with a t14s have working sound?

00:32 <dgilmore> https://www.irccloud.com/pastebin/FuqfK5m7/

00:32 <dgilmore> I also have the alsa ucm profiles installed

00:33 <dgilmore> but also claims no cards are installed and I do not have any saved alsa states to clean up

00:54 <dgilmore> [ 29.220290] platform sound: deferred probe pending: snd-x1e80100: WCD Playback: codec dai not found

01:00 <dgilmore> https://www.irccloud.com/pastebin/x2Ti6uEr/

03:06 <steev> dgilmore: i had it... but not now

03:06 <steev> i haven't looked into it at all though

03:21 <dgilmore> It's never worked for me. Just started digging in. I added patches to add the EC driver, which doesn't seem to work for me

03:22 <steev> i think i attempted to try the ec driver and got a bluescreen but i'll be honest, i kinda took a week to just, not touch anything so i haven't really looked into if i screwed something up

03:25 <dgilmore> https://lkml.indiana.edu/2509.1/01857.html is the latest version. The first was posted on the 5th

03:26 <steev> if you're using the defconfig, i think its missing some codecs

03:26 <dgilmore> Its loaded. But keyboard backlight control doesn't work. Neither does the sound control buttons. Which is why I dug into sound

03:26 <dgilmore> I'm using fedora's config

03:30 <steev> the sound keys should work even without audio driver or ec

03:46 <steev> krzk: for the qcom-linux qcom_laptops.config could you also add SQUASHFS_XATTR=y ?

05:04 <JensGlathe[m]> <dgilmore> "anyone with a t14s have working..." <- Yes. When I‘m on EL1

06:05 <steev> i dunno what i broke but i have some message about either missing ucm profile or mixer based something

06:14 <steev> ah, i had a stale asound.state file

06:18 <apple-corps[m]> <JensGlathe[m]> "os-prober is borked (permission..." <- My experience as well

06:18 <apple-corps[m]> On the vivobook s15

11:42 <dgilmore> JensGlathe[m]: clearly it's me that's a problem. There must be something turned off in Fedora's config that's needed

11:45 <JensGlathe[m]> You could take a stab at it with [this wiki here](https://github.com/jglathe/linux_ms_dev_kit/wiki/Enabling-sound-on-the-HP-Omnibook-X14,-Lenovo-Thinkbook-16). Worked for my T14s, too.

11:46 <xeliteCJF> Today had a little chat with gpt about the 'no sound' on my ASUS S15. and walked to all the RX/INP/MUX by the end have a script what set whats needed. Still have no sound but can trigger an error from the qcom soundwire driver.

11:46 <JensGlathe[m]> a different error

11:47 <xeliteCJF> here is the script

11:47 <xeliteCJF> #!/bin/bash

11:47 <xeliteCJF> # WSA debug script for ASUS XElite S15

11:47 <xeliteCJF> # Checks SoundWire masters for errors

11:47 <xeliteCJF> CARD=0 # ALSA card

11:47 <xeliteCJF> # Applies routing, MUX/RX/INP, PA gain, COMP switches, plays a test tone

11:47 <xeliteCJF> PA_GAIN=15

11:47 <xeliteCJF> VOL=30

11:47 <xeliteCJF> TEST_WAV="test.wav"

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Checking for WSA codec presence ==="

11:47 <xeliteCJF> if ! amixer -c $CARD controls | grep -q 'WSA'; then

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "No WSA controls found on card $CARD. Ensure the DSP is loaded."

11:47 <xeliteCJF> exit 1

11:47 <xeliteCJF> fi

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Checking recent SoundWire CMD errors ==="

11:47 <xeliteCJF> CMD_ERRORS=$(dmesg | tail -n 100 | grep -i 'qcom-soundwire.*SWR CMD error')

11:47 <xeliteCJF> if [ -n "$CMD_ERRORS" ]; then

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "Warning: Detected recent SoundWire CMD errors:"

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "$CMD_ERRORS"

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "A reboot or module reload may be required to clear stuck FIFOs."

11:47 <xeliteCJF> else

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "No recent SoundWire CMD errors detected."

11:47 <xeliteCJF> fi

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Listing SoundWire masters ==="

11:47 <xeliteCJF> for m in /sys/bus/soundwire/devices/sdw-master-*-0; do

11:47 <xeliteCJF> echo "Found SoundWire master: $m"

11:47 <xeliteCJF> done

11:48 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Setting up WSA speaker amps ==="

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='SpkrLeft WSA MODE' 0

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='SpkrRight WSA MODE' 0

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_COMP1 Switch' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_COMP2 Switch' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA EAR SPKR PA Gain' $PA_GAIN

11:48 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Enabling RX inputs ==="

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_RX0 INP0' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_RX0 INP1' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_RX1 INP0' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_RX1 INP1' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Unmuting RX MIX ==="

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_RX0_MIX Digital Mute' 0

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_RX1_MIX Digital Mute' 0

11:48 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Setting RX MUXes ==="

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA RX0 MUX' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA RX1 MUX' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA RX_MIX0 MUX' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA RX_MIX1 MUX' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Connecting MultiMedia stream to WSA amps ==="

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_AIF_VI Mixer WSA_SPKR_VI_1' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_AIF_VI Mixer WSA_SPKR_VI_2' 1

11:48 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Setting Digital Volume ==="

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_RX0 Digital Volume' $VOL

11:48 <xeliteCJF> amixer -c $CARD cset name='WSA WSA_RX1 Digital Volume' $VOL

11:48 <xeliteCJF> # Generate short test tone if missing

11:48 <xeliteCJF> if [ ! -f "$TEST_WAV" ]; then

11:48 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Generating 1-second 440Hz test tone ==="

11:49 <xeliteCJF> sox -n -r 48000 -c 2 "$TEST_WAV" synth 1 sine 440

11:49 <xeliteCJF> fi

11:49 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== Playing test tone to trigger DSP ==="

11:49 <xeliteCJF> aplay -D plughw:$CARD,0 "$TEST_WAV"

11:49 <xeliteCJF> echo "=== WSA initialization complete ==="

11:49 <xeliteCJF> to trigger

11:49 <xeliteCJF> [ 252.468400] qcom-soundwire 6b10000.soundwire: qcom_swrm_irq_handler: SWR CMD error, fifo status 0x4e00c00f, flushing fifo

11:49 <xeliteCJF> [ 288.128245] qcom-soundwire 6b10000.soundwire: qcom_swrm_irq_handler: SWR CMD error, fifo status 0x4e00c705, flushing fifo

11:49 <xeliteCJF> i played aplay -D plughw:CARD=X1E80100ASUSViv,DEV=1 test.wav

11:55 <deathmist> xeliteCJF: for future reference please don't post long multi-line things, just look at https://oftc.catirclogs.org/aarch64-laptops to see what people on IRC see

11:55 <deathmist> surprised it didn't even get turned to the long links usually seen when matrix users do this

11:56 <deathmist> ah actually you're on IRC aren't you?

11:57 <travmurav[m]> given how on matrix it also was a bunch of single messages, they are xD

11:57 <deathmist> worst of both worlds :D

11:58 <travmurav[m]> but more on topic, what was the setting that made speakers make beautiful smell of boiling plastic, again?

11:59 <JensGlathe[m]> pff

12:00 <xeliteCJF> sorry for this. I will keep that in mind.

12:06 <xeliteCJF> Anyway is someone spot a problem with the script, let me know. I digging around with this no sound for a while now and use the headset all the time give me no fun

13:58 <neobrain[m]> bamse: I got the kernel 6.16.6 update today, indeed the GPU errors are fixed there too :)

14:05 <bamse> neobrain[m]: thanks for confirming

17:09 <steev> dgilmore: on my t14s, i had to clone the upstream alsa-ucm-conf project, rsync the ucm2 contents into /usr/share/alsa, stop the alsa-restore service, delete the bunk /var/lib/alsa/asound.state and then restart the system. i'm using https://gitlab.com/Linaro/arm64-laptops/linux/-/commits/qcom-laptops kernel (with v3 of ec driver reverted, and v4 applied though, it doesn't seem to automatically load the ec driver)

18:36 <dgilmore> https://www.irccloud.com/pastebin/6SyhNpw4/

19:40 <steev> yeah i get that once i load it, but it doesn't load automagically here

19:48 <dgilmore> the ec driver seems to be loaded

19:49 <dgilmore> it was automatic here

21:05 <crpalmer> I'm trying to figure out audio on my Yoga Slim7x. I have a kernel that I built with a Frankenstein .config based on Ubuntu's / Fedora's / random changes I made to get other functonality working. In this kernel, audio is working. I tried making a clean .config using tuxmake (using Linaro's qcom-laptops version of defconfig / qcom_laptops.config). In my clean config, audio is not working. Has anyone else dealt

21:05 <crpalmer> with something similar or can point me at what I changed that happened to also make audio work?

21:08 <crpalmer> dgilmore: This is likely the same as what you're experiencing on the T14s as I've been told the Rawhide kernel doesn't have working audio for the Slim7x.

21:11 <anthony25> It should work by default as long as you have the audio firmware

21:15 <crpalmer> " and something similar is the only dmesg entry. It's definitely .config related as I built exactly the same kernel code with a different .config and it was working.

21:15 <crpalmer> Damn it.

21:16 <crpalmer> devices_deferred says "soundsnd-x1e80100: WSA Playback: codec dai not found

21:16 <crpalmer> " (I screwed up the previous line using / to start the path). That's what's also in the dmesg.

21:16 <anthony25> https://github.com/linux-msm/audioreach-topology

21:17 <anthony25> I thought fedora was including it in their qcom firmwares

21:18 <crpalmer> I used the Ubuntu tool to extract the firmware from my windows partition and it is functional with my current firmware. Just not the linaro generated .config.

21:19 <anthony25> Just regarding the audio, there's no volume protection, so you can break the speakers, and for some people, breaking the speakers has also created problems with other components of the laptop

21:20 <anthony25> crpalmer: ha so linaro branch with the Ubuntu config works, but not with defconfig?

21:22 <crpalmer> anthony: Not the Ubuntu config. I have been told it is broken. I have my own .config in which it works but I'm trying to clean up the mess I made making random changes to it while trying to get a booting system. Just not with the defconfig I am generating with tuxmake from the linaro branch.

21:27 <anthony25> Then I would check if you changed some WSA configs, like making sure that SND_SOC_WSA881X=m

21:30 <crpalmer> I didn't have that set in my old .config, but I'll enable it and see what happens.

21:31 <anthony25> it should be in the defconfig

21:31 <anthony25> look also at the WCD configs

21:34 <crpalmer> You're right. I was in the wrong branch. I was checking the upstream 6.17 version instead. It is enabled in my linaro build.

23:02 <_mike_> Hi

23:03 <_mike_> What's the status of support on non elite snapdragon x's these days?

23:03 <_mike_> Like a Lenovo ideapad slim 5 for example